Restaurant
My Sugar Pie — Zionsville, Indiana
40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077
My Sugar Pie is a gourmet pie bakery in downtown Zionsville, located on East Pine Street just off Main. The shop bakes whole pies and pie slices in fruit, cream, classic, and seasonal flavors that rotate throughout the year.
The pies
My Sugar Pie offers a wide range of homemade pies, including fruit pies, cream pies, custard-style pies, and seasonal specials. Pies are sold by the slice and as whole pies for take-home orders, gifts, holidays, and special occasions. The shop also publishes a printable pie menu and offers gift cards and seasonal slice specials.
Ordering and shipping
Pies can be ordered online for pickup, and many flavors can be shipped nationwide through the shop's online store. For shipped orders, the site provides pie care and reheating instructions to keep pies at their best on arrival.
Planning your visit
My Sugar Pie is at 40 E. Pine Street, just off Main Street in downtown Zionsville. Pickup orders ask for a chosen pickup date at checkout — check the current hours and the order page on its website, or its Google Maps listing, before planning a visit.
Parking Information
- Street parking is available along Main Street and nearby streets, but fills quickly on busy weekends.
- The largest public parking lot is located at the northwest corner of Main Street and Sycamore Road, with access from both Main Street and First Street. A second lot is located at the southwest corner of Main Street and Pine Street.
- Additional parking is available on nearby side streets and in public lots throughout the Village, including Lions Park, all within a short walk of downtown.